Riffs on a Trusted Favorite: Extra Pepperoni, Three Ways

You know that one album you can play on repeat — no matter the mood — and it never, ever lets you down? That’s our Extra Pepperoni pizza: a veritable blanket of pepperoni over mozzarella and our seasoned tomato sauce. Reliable, satisfying, and always hitting the right notes. And with spring weather teasing us with sunbreaks, then more rain — so much rain — there’s a comfort after a long day in knowing you can count on Pagliacci for a quick, delicious meal. 

Many of our regulars have their favorite riff on the pepperoni — a custom ingredient or two — and we’ve compiled the top hits:  

First up: Pepperoni and Mushroom. The mushrooms add a subtle, earthy note that harmonizes with the pepperoni’s zest. True to the spirit of the original, with another layer of flavor, this one keeps things interesting. 

Next, Pepperoni and Olive. Think bright and briny, a perfect counterpoint to pepperoni’s swagger. Even a small tweak can give an old favorite a whole new vibe, and this combo proves it big time.  

Finally, for those craving an epic finale: Pepperoni, Mushroom, and Olive. It’s earthy, savory, tangy — pretty much the encore everyone’s shouting for.  

Sometimes comfort in the classics is exactly what you need. Whether these variations are already your go-to, or you’re looking for a twist on your favorite to light a spark, we’re here to deliver the same consistency, quality, and flavor you count on. Whether you’re flying solo or feeding a crew of pizza lovers, we’ve got you covered.  

Order yours now!